Article Wednesday, 09 Jun 2010
By: Dick Morris
The drop in the stock market (now
about 1,000 points on the Dow) is a graphic indication of the stark
fact that we are entering the infamous double dip of the recession,
long feared and predicted.
The economy is not in a V after all (down and then up), but in a W
(down, up, down again, and then, finally, up). And the cause of the
second dip is not the recession itself, but the cure administered
to it by President Obama and the Democratic Congress.
Consider the indications (data provided by the New America
Foundation, analysis by Sherle R. Schwenninger and Samuel Sherraden):
• GDP growth has been 2.2 percent, 5.6 percent, and 3.2 percent for
each of the last three quarters, well below the rebounds typical in
past recessions.
• Total civilian employment has rebounded by only 1 percent since
the depth of the unemployment five months ago. In 1973, at a
comparable point, it had rebounded by 7 percent. In 1981, by 8
percent. In 1990, by 4 percent. And in 2001 by 3 percent. U-6, the
broadest measure of unemployment, stands at 17.1 percent, and we
need 12.8 million new jobs.
• Housing prices have dropped by 30 percent since 2006 and "many
economists expect housing prices to decline at least another 10
percent," according to Schwenninger and Sherraden.
• While corporate profits are 30.6 percent higher than a year ago,
wages are up by 1.6 percent, less than half their rate of increase
two years ago.
• Financial-sector profits make up 35.7 percent of all domestic
corporate profits. These gains are driven by trading revenue, which
does not reflect real economic growth. Schwenninger and Sherraden
report, "In the first quarter of 2010, Goldman Sachs, Morgan
Stanley, and Bank of America earned 72 percent, 45 percent, and 16
percent of their net revenue [respectively] from trading profits."
• Personal savings dropped from a high of almost 6 percent to 2.7
percent in March 2010, so households have cut their debt by just
$300 billion since it peaked in 2008. Household debt, which rose
from 60 percent of GDP in 1990 to almost 100 percent in 2008, has
dropped to 97 percent. It has a long way to go before it's down
enough to free consumers to spend more.
• Meanwhile, retail sales have averaged only a 1.7 percent increase
over the past three quarters, half of which was to restock
inventories. Schwenninger and Sherraden note "in a typical
recovery, the rebound is closer to 3.5 percent." And most of that
increase is due to expanding government cash transfer payments,
which now make up 18.3 percent of personal income. "Excluding
transfer payments, personal income increased just 0.3 percent since
the third quarter of 2009."
• Stimulus spending, which has failed to generate private-sector
growth, is winding down. Only 43 percent of the tax benefits and
entitlement spending remain to be doled out, as does 63 percent of
the contracts, grants, and loans in the stimulus package.
• The strengthening of the dollar due to the collapse of the euro
will dry up U.S. export trade. Exports to EU nations account for 21
percent of American and 20 percent of Chinese exports. Schwenninger
and Sherraden note, "A European slowdown will reduce demand for the
two primary engines of world economic growth."
But this second downturn in the economy will be accompanied by
inflation, making it worse than the first recession. With interest
rates set to rise (because the Fed is no longer massively
purchasing securities to keep them down), taxes set to go up
(because of Obama's ideology), and global energy use about to
increase, sending prices higher (because the rest of the world is
recovering), prices have to go up. But with no growth in real
personal income and household credit close to all-time highs, there
is not enough demand to pay the higher prices, so a deeper slump
will ensue.
The solution? Cut taxes. And bring down the deficit through massive
spending cuts. Reduce our borrowing needs by slashing our spending.
Free up capital to feed job growth.
It should be evident to all that Obamanomics is a disaster. It
reminds one of nothing so much as the medieval practice of bleeding
the patient to make him well by expelling the evil spirits that
dwelt within. When the patient did not recover, they just bled him
more and, when he died, they just said that the spirits killed him.
The practice of spending, borrowing, and then taxing to fuel job
growth is the modern analogy.